Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Speaker vs Speaker: Judge slapping his own face? - Malaysiakini

By Kim Quek Sep 9, 09 4:55pm

A tragic yet hilarious court proceeding took place in the Ipoh High Court on Sept 8 when the judge blatantly contradicted himself in dismissing a suit brought by Perak's Pakatan Rakyat speaker against the state's Barisan Nasional speaker (yes, two speakers in the Perak assembly).

Judge Azahar Mohamed rejected V Sivakumar's suit to seek damages from R Ganesan for assault and false imprisonment during the chaotic and violent state assembly sitting on May 7.

He said the court had no jurisdiction to hear the case due to Federal Constitution Article 72 stipulating that "the validity of any proceeding in any state assembly cannot be questioned in any court".

And yet in the same breath he declared that "the decision of the legislative assembly to remove the plaintiff as speaker and to appoint the defendant was conclusive and had been fairly determined by the state assembly on May 7, 2009."

Now, the crux of the entire contention between the two speakers is: Who is on the right side of law in the violent tussle for the speaker's chair on May 7?

By declaring Ganesan as the rightful speaker, Judge Azahar is in fact making a legal judgment. Is that not a breach of Article 72? How come he has no jurisdiction to hear Sivakumar's grievances but has jurisdiction to judge Ganesan as legal speaker?

Is that not a contradiction of the highest order?

Apart from this atrocious double standard applied by the judge, the main flaw of the judgment is the inability to differentiate between assembly proceeding and criminal behaviour.

What Sivakumar is seeking is redress for the unlawful physical violence inflicted on him. And Article 72 covers only businesses conducted in the assembly - not unlawful and criminal act.

Judge Azahar has therefore wrongly used Article 72 to come to his judgment. To make it very clear that this is the case, I will quote in full the relevant clauses in Article 72 (Clauses 1 & 2) and explain the reasons why.

* Clause 1: The validity of any proceedings in the Legislative Assembly of any State shall not be questioned in any court.

* Clause 2: No body shall be liable to any proceedings in any court in respect of anything said or vote given by him when taking part in proceedings of the Legislative Assembly of any State or of any committee thereof.

Note the operative words "proceedings" in Clause 1 and "anything said or any vote given" in Clause 2. It is abundantly clear what Article 72 refers to are the speeches and resolutions made in the assembly, not any criminal or unlawful act.

Tragedy and comedy


But what happened on May 7 was complete pandemonium and chaos in the assembly hall. There was no chance to conduct any business at all, least of all any resolution passed. In fact, the only business done on that day was the address by the Perak Regent Raja Nazrin Shah.

And how was Sivakumar "replaced" by Ganesan during that pandemonium?

While Sivakumar was sitting in the speaker's chair, hordes of police personnel entered the assembly hall, allegedly on Ganesan's order, and physically lifted, carried, dragged and moved speaker Sivakumar into a room where he was forcibly detained until the assembly sitting was over.

And as soon as Sivakumar was removed from the hall, police personnel escorted Ganesan into the hall and ushered him to the speakers chair, with police personnel making a line to stand guard in front of Ganesan to prevent any assemblymen from reaching the speaker's chair.

The entire tragedy-comedy was stage-managed by the police, and it is therefore more appropriate to say that while Sivakumar was elected by the assembly through a resolution, Ganesan was physically planted into the speaker's chair by the police. And that about sums up what happened on that tragic-hilarious day.

And since Judge Azahar appears to be so respectful of the constitutional principle of separation of power as demonstrated by his professed adherence to Article 72, is it not puzzling that he should have chosen to ignore completely the heinous violation of the doctrine of separation of power when hordes of police personnel invaded the assembly to physically replace one speaker with another?

Is it not another shining example of double standard in the Malaysia Boleh tradition?

After the series of judicial decisions that appear to wantonly trample the constitution and the law following the shameful power grab in Perak, the latest low represented by Azahar's decision makes us wonder how much lower our judiciary can sink into, as many more judicial decisions in the same series are still pending.

37 comments:

美麗公主 said...

你怎麼能經過一片海,而忘記它的藍?.........................

yahoo said...

生命是一頓豐富的宴席,有人卻寧可挨餓..............................

元氣 said...

快樂是你與生俱來的權力,它不應該取決於你完成什麼。 ........................................

IdrisAMK said...

Pelik juga dengan Pemimpin PR. Kata Kerajaan rampasan haram tapi satu persatu serah. last sekali serah kater. Skang hadir sidang. alang - alang celup pekasam biar sampai kepangkal lengan. kenapa harus mengalah.

任安任安 said...

安心亞寫真top1069拓網交友做愛自拍免費情色影片寫真集美女正妹照片正妹貼圖正妹視訊250av女優免費影片旺來出品辣妹寫真鋼管秀旺來風情寫真秀-辣妹過招旺來風情寫真秀旺來蓬萊仙山寫真集 vcd旺旺仙貝的狂想境地早洩韭南籽早期歐美a片早期范冰冰照片早春小老婆日本三性影片美女 視訊洪爺sex免費看a片論壇秘密情人影音視訊網 bt成人網av一葉情貼影色網18 禁一葉情貼影入口女生自衛影片免費聊天女同志聊天室成人聊天室做愛影片網交聊天室性愛姿勢免費av影片觀看拓峰交友plus論壇hbo論壇一夜情視訊聊天室五分鐘護半身視訊美女激情網愛聊天室臺灣情色網

柏辰 said...

最偉大的天才如果終日躺在草地上,讓微風吹拂,眼望天空,那麼溫柔的 靈感也不會光顧他的。 ....................................................

邱志誠 said...

Practice what you preach.......................................................

Rosalinda21087 said...

A liar is not believed when he speaks the truth. .........................................

GeraldF_Rotter雅慧 said...

很用心的blog,推推哦 ........................................

俊淑娟美 said...

舊書不厭百回讀,熟讀深思子自知。........................................

佳蓉 said...

援交友聊天室 成人視訊jaanli 視訊聊天交友1758 素人自拍,情色小站 av999電影院 a片 男同志網gay圖片 咆哮老鼠concert 高雄寂寞小站 成人情色 視訊21sex 176視訊聊天室 avdvd情色影片 love104 視訊聊天室 摸摸耳小遊戲 1111非常好色6 0下載 情人輔助品視訊交友 成人視訊ynbcom 情色a片-情色小站 aio交友愛情館 18x us視訊聊天 內衣名模寫真 南人情色論壇 東東成人論談 xxvideo 倉井空免費a影片 免費視訊173liveshow google台灣 賓館偷拍影片 s383情色大網咖 歐美潮吹短片 104視訊美女 0951撥打電話下載 0204免費下載短片 免費視訊交友 援交情人視訊聊天室 avdvd免費無碼a片 視訊網愛聊天室85cc yam天空影音 104川藏第一美女視訊 無碼視訊情色小站 色美媚,洪爺的家 杜雷斯免費影片 網愛交友網 視訊甜心寶貝av貼片區 aio辣妺視訊 東京熱情色影片 交友網愛戀之旅 上班族酒趴網 免費視訊monico sex520貼片

建霖 said...

your artical is so funny!! it make me so happy!! ........................................

韋佳順雯 said...

Use a book as a bee does flowers. ............................................................

俊偉 said...

77p2p影片網 口交 777口交超辣天堂 777成人區 777色情片 性交 巨乳 一葉情 18禁 裸照 777影片網 77p2p 77p2p影片網卡通 77p2p影片網 77p2p影片網中文版 77p2p影片網卡通 77p2p2 a片 a圖 走光 77p2p卡通 77p2p巨乳 77p2p成人區 77p2p成人影片區 77p2p成人影片網 自拍寫真 77p2p影片 77p2p影片區 77p2p影片網 77p2p影片網中文版 77p2p影片網卡通 飯島愛 77p2p影片網臺灣 77p2p影片網線上觀看 77p2p歐美 性交 77美女dvd影片 789av辣妹網 裸圖 穿幫眉眉 情色 性高潮 鹹濕人妻 打砲 人妻無碼 大奶 自慰 高潮 爆乳 7r成人入口

溫淑芬 said...

Where did you purchase this product?.............................................................

靖福 said...

果然很有意思呀....這當然要頂一頂呀.................................................................

姿吟姿吟 said...

在莫非定律中有項笨蛋定律:「一個組織中的笨蛋,恆大於等於三分之二。」.................................................................                           

陳湖 said...

欣賞是一種美德~回應是最大的支持^^.................................................................

凱文凱文 said...

成熟,就是有能力適應生活中的模糊。.................................................................

張怡 said...

噴泉的高度,不會超過它的源頭。一個人的事業也是如此,它的成就絕不會超過自己的信念。.................................................................

于倫 said...

人不可以求其備,必捨其所短,取其所長............................................................

JasonBirk佳琪 said...

人生最可憐的是半途而廢,最可悲的是喪失信心,最遺憾的是浪費時間,最可怕的是沒有恆心。..................................................

rreynolds385 said...

人生中最好的禮物就是屬於自己的一部份..................................................

楊儀卉 said...

工作,是愛的具體化~~~~努力吧!............................................................

陳佑發 said...

時時關心,時時感動。..................................................

宮惠如宮惠如 said...

出遊不拘名勝,有景就是好的..................................................................

佳瑩佳瑩 said...

人生中最好的禮物就是屬於自己的一部份............................................................

童祖如童祖如 said...

要求適合自己的愛情方式,是會得到更多,還是會錯過一個真正愛你的人。..................................................................

小袁璇 said...

人生中最好的禮物就是屬於自己的一部份............................................................

凱v胡倫 said...

Learn wisdom by the follies of others.............................................................

文王廷 said...

要保持更新呦,加油!!!期待你的新文章!!!............................................................

文王廷 said...

您的blog蠻不錯的耶,祝你快樂哦!期待您的更新!............................................................

江趙雲虹趙雲虹仁昆 said...

開懷幸福的生活,是每個人的夢想~~希望大家都能夠實現!...............................................................

陳欣陳玟珮陳玟珮琦 said...

來打聲招呼-大家好!!!..................................................

瑰潼 said...

你怎麼能經過一片海,而忘記它的藍?......................................................................

方峻君 said...

愛,拆開來是心和受兩個字。用心去接受對方的一切,用心去愛對方的所有。......................................................................

储涵 said...

死亡是悲哀的,但活得不快樂更悲哀。.. ... ............................................................